Voters Chose the 120th Congress. Don’t Let the 119th Legislate in the Dark.
I gave myself half a day to enjoy the midterms victory. But just as we collectively caught our breath from this administration’s second wrecking ball, knowing that the future could be brighter, the lame duck session pulled the rug out from under our feet. This eight week period can be a fraught time when those voted out of power still maintain control, and want to push through every possible bill they can, and this lame duck is looking like a doozie. The unfortunate fact is the midterm elections dramatically changed who will sit in the 120th Congress come January, not this one. Even still, you would think that the election results would have emboldened Democrats to stand firm and hold the line until 2027.
Instead Senate Democrats started off the lame duck session without a unified stance of resistance when 22 Democrats joined all but one Republican to advance debate on the Trump-backed “Bipartisan” American “Affordability” And “Jobs” Act (BAAJA), S. 5653. As we have previously mentioned in our Substack, this deregulation package transfers power away from citizens and the courts and into the hands of corporations, gutting our supposed bedrock environmental laws including the National Environmental Policy Act, the Endangered Species Act, the Clean Water Act and the National Historic Preservation Act. To be clear, this bill should have been dead on arrival, with the Democrats having the absolute power to block its consideration. Instead, on a vote of 73 to 25, the bill is now in play and is a very real threat to everyone’s ability to fight for their community and the public lands they love.
And BAJAA is not the only threat looming in this lame duck session. It’s themes of destruction, deregulation and favoring corporations over citizens and the environment already lives in the Fix Our Forests Act (FOFA) and the Save Our Sequoias Act (SOSA), which can’t pass as stand alone bills, but may hitch a ride on the National Defense Authorization Act (NDAA) or get shoved into the Farm Bill or government funding which must be addressed by December 11th.
While this all seems bleak and rather demoralizing after such a pronounced result at the polls, Democrats can still stop these bills in the lame duck session. But more than that, Democrats can embody the spirit of the incoming 120th Congress and shift back to protecting people’s rights and the environment rather than trading away community and public lands protections to oil, gas, coal, logging, mining, data centers and other development interests.

Stand Firm and Fight, Don’t Give an Inch
First things first, the Democrats need to be prepared to shut down the government if Republicans refuse to pass clean continuing resolutions that push votes on appropriations, Farm Bill and NDAA out to March or heck, why not until the end of September 2027. No other bills should be passed.
Admit the Promises of BAAJA are False:
Next, Democrats need to call out the false promises of BAAJA. First let’s talk about affordability. Can we all use an extra $50 per year in our bank account? Sure. But does that miniscule amount, which won’t likely reach us until 2040, truly make our lives or the energy we use more affordable? Absolutely not! So to those Democrats who feel like they ran on a platform to reduce energy prices and affordability – this is not your bill.
How about BAAJA’s climate change and clean energy claims. Let’s be clear, BAAJA eliminates foundational laws that safeguard our environment not just for renewable energy (wind and solar), but for ALL ENERGY, including oil, gas, coal, and forest biomass (which is even dirtier than coal). But its provisions don’t stop with energy projects, BAAJA also applies to any federal project, like logging our public forests, building roads, ski resorts, and data centers, to name a few, all while destroying habitat, historical sites, sacred sites and archaeological sites and polluting our land and waters in the process. This is not a clean energy bill and it is not a climate bill. Even the most conservative firms that are trying to find a way to say that BAAJA will reduce emissions are hard pressed to come up with more than a hypothetical 3% decrease in emissions in 14 years! And even that number is overly inflated, because it does not take into consideration that the Trump Administration will overwhelmingly favor permits for fossil fuels, not wind or solar, and that those fossil fuel permits will be locked in place for generations. In fact Trump is already on record saying regardless of what this bill says he will not approve Wind projects. But the other thing the emission analyses do not include is the carbon emissions from development and destruction of the natural world which this bill would accelerate, such as increased logging on public forests, in light of the fact that BAAJA would essentially nullify NEPA and the ESA for ALL federal projects, including logging of mature trees, clearcutting old-growth forests, and post-fire clearcutting on public lands. Nor do the self-serving and misleading think tank analyses cited by BAAJA’s proponents include the corresponding decrease in the ability of these ravaged ecosystems to sequester carbon that is already in the atmosphere. BAAJA will not reduce emissions, it will simply lead to more emissions now and into the future. BAAJA’s NEPA and ESA rollbacks alone, and the increased logging that would result, would cause a net increase in carbon emissions, based on a previous analysis in a similar legislative circumstance. Again, the analyses from the think tanks hired to promote BAAJA did not include these emissions.
Proposed Amendments Will Not Fix This Bill:
BAAJA, FOFA and SOSA should die with the 119th Congress, and stay dead. Democrats owe that to the 120th Congress and to all the voters that worked so hard to transfer power into their hands. Call your U.S. Senators, 202-224-3121, and tell your Senators to vote NO on the profoundly destructive BAAJA bill, S. 5653, or any version of it.

